Skip to content

Head to head

A Wizard of Earthsea vs The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings takes it by 0.5, 9.6 against 9.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of A Wizard of Earthsea
A Wizard of Earthsea

1968 · Essential

  • Prose with the rhythm of a told legend, plain enough for a twelve-year-old
  • Magic built on true names, with a cost attached to every spell cast
  • The narration keeps its distance, so Ged can feel observed rather than known
Cover of The Lord of the Rings
The Lord of the Rings

1954 · Masterpiece

  • Middle-earth's languages, histories and geography give it unmatched depth
  • Sam and Frodo's friendship is one of fiction's great depictions of loyalty
  • The long opening in the Shire and Old Forest tests newcomers' patience

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.49.7
Story
8.69.6
Writing
9.69.1
Characters
8.79.0

At a glance

FactA Wizard of EarthseaThe Lord of the Rings
Released196829 July 1954
AuthorUrsula K. Le GuinJ.R.R. Tolkien
PublisherParnassus PressGeorge Allen & Unwin Limited
Pages205 pages (first edition)1178
GenreAdventure · Fantasy · Coming of ageAdventure · Fantasy

The two verdicts

A Wizard of Earthsea

A Wizard of Earthsea: the wizard-school novel that made power a moral problem

*A Wizard of Earthsea* earns its place near the top of the catalogue because it does so much in so little space and does it without a wasted word. Its account of power, and of the discipline needed to carry it, has aged better than most fantasy written since, and its prose remains a model of clarity. The score stops short of the very top tier for reasons Le Guin herself acknowledged: a narration that keeps its hero at a distance, a cast with almost no room for women, and a middle stretch that summarises where it could dramatise. Those limits are real, and the later books exist partly to answer them. As a single novel, though, it is still the one later wizard stories have to measure themselves against.

Read the full review →

The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings: the template for modern fantasy remains its high-water mark

The Lord of the Rings has faults that are easy to list: a meandering opening, a narrow range of female roles and a high style that is not to all tastes. Yet the depth of its world, the moral seriousness of its themes and the emotional power of its central friendship are unrivalled. It is an all-time landmark, and it continues to justify its reputation.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.