Skip to content

Head to head

Akira vs The Sandman

Dead level: both score 9.4. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Akira
Akira

1982 · Essential

  • Otomo's Neo-Tokyo is drawn down to the last window frame, and it is always moving
  • Chases and collapses read with a clarity most action comics never reach
  • The middle volumes stretch some set pieces well past their narrative purpose
Cover of The Sandman
The Sandman

1989 · Essential

  • The Endless are among the most memorable characters in modern fantasy
  • Standalone tales such as A Midsummer Night's Dream rank with comics' finest
  • The early issues lean on DC horror and superhero trappings that feel dated

Where the gap is

Art
9.98.6
Story
9.19.5
Pacing
8.58.7
Characters
8.79.6

At a glance

FactAkiraThe Sandman
Released20 December 19821989
WriterKatsuhiro OtomoNeil Gaiman
ArtistKatsuhiro OtomoSam Kieth
PublisherKodanshaDC Comics
Issues120 chapters, serialised in Young Magazine from 20 December 1982 to 25 June 1990; collected in six volumes75
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · SeinenDrama · Fantasy · Graphic Novel

The two verdicts

Akira

Akira: the manga is the whole city, and the film was only ever a map of it

*Akira* is held just short of the very top tier by its own size: a middle stretch that indulges set pieces, and a hero who stays thinner than the people around him. Everything else is close to the best the medium has managed. Otomo built a city in ink and then let the story pull it apart, with a control of space, motion and scale that later artists are still studying. The supporting cast turns a chase story into a political one, and the long form gives the ideas room to become disturbing rather than merely loud. For anyone who has seen the film, the manga is not a footnote but the main event; for anyone who has seen neither, it is the better place to begin.

Read the full review →

The Sandman

The Sandman is a vast mythic tapestry about stories, change and the price of pride

The Sandman is an extraordinary achievement, a rich and moving meditation on myth, responsibility and change that expanded what mainstream comics could be. Its uneven early issues, inconsistent art and occasionally meandering structure prevent a perfect score. A 9.4 recognises an exceptional series that remains one of the most influential works in the medium.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.