Skip to content

Head to head

Akira vs X-Men: The Dark Phoenix Saga

Akira takes it by 0.7, 9.4 against 8.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Akira
Akira

1982 · Essential

  • Otomo's Neo-Tokyo is drawn down to the last window frame, and it is always moving
  • Chases and collapses read with a clarity most action comics never reach
  • The middle volumes stretch some set pieces well past their narrative purpose
Cover of X-Men: The Dark Phoenix Saga
  • A genuinely epic story of power, temptation and loss
  • John Byrne and Terry Austin's clean, dynamic art defined the era
  • Dense thought balloons and captions feel dated and overwritten

Where the gap is

Art
9.98.8
Story
9.18.9
Pacing
8.57.9
Characters
8.78.9

At a glance

FactAkiraX-Men: The Dark Phoenix Saga
Released20 December 19821980
WriterKatsuhiro OtomoChris Claremont
ArtistKatsuhiro OtomoJohn Byrne
PublisherKodanshaMarvel Comics
Issues120 chapters, serialised in Young Magazine from 20 December 1982 to 25 June 1990; collected in six volumes9
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · SeinenSci-Fi · Drama · Superhero

The two verdicts

Akira

Akira: the manga is the whole city, and the film was only ever a map of it

*Akira* is held just short of the very top tier by its own size: a middle stretch that indulges set pieces, and a hero who stays thinner than the people around him. Everything else is close to the best the medium has managed. Otomo built a city in ink and then let the story pull it apart, with a control of space, motion and scale that later artists are still studying. The supporting cast turns a chase story into a political one, and the long form gives the ideas room to become disturbing rather than merely loud. For anyone who has seen the film, the manga is not a footnote but the main event; for anyone who has seen neither, it is the better place to begin.

Read the full review →

X-Men: The Dark Phoenix Saga

The Dark Phoenix Saga is the X-Men's grand cosmic tragedy, dated dialogue and all

The Dark Phoenix Saga is a landmark of superhero storytelling, combining cosmic scope, memorable villains and a genuinely tragic central arc. Its dated writing style, uneven pacing and troubling framing of female power hold it back from the very top. An 8.7 recognises an excellent, influential saga that remains one of the defining X-Men stories.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.