Skip to content

Head to head

Akira vs Redline

Akira takes it by 0.8, 9.4 against 8.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Akira
Akira

1988 · Essential

  • Densely detailed Neo-Tokyo feels lived-in, decaying and genuinely vast
  • The motorbike chases and light trails are still imitated decades later
  • Condensing a sprawling manga leaves the political plotting confusing
Cover of Redline
Redline

2009 · Excellent

  • Hand-drawn racing with heavy black shadows and smear frames no CG pipeline would allow
  • The Yellowline opener sets the rules, the stakes and the style in ten minutes
  • The plot is a straight line with a romance stapled on, and it knows it

Where the gap is

Sound
9.69.1
Story
8.37.4
Animation
10.09.9
Characters
8.57.9

At a glance

FactAkiraRedline
Released16 July 198814 August 2009
StudioTokyo Movie Shinsha, TMS EntertainmentMadhouse
DirectorKatsuhiro OtomoTakeshi Koike
Episodes11 (feature film)
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · DramaAction · Sci-Fi · Romance
Status—Completed

The two verdicts

Akira

Akira: the hand-drawn apocalypse that redrew the map for animation

Akira's narrative compression is a real weakness, and its characters beyond the central pair are thin. But as a work of animation, design and sound it remains close to peerless, and its influence on the medium is difficult to overstate. It has been celebrated for decades as a cornerstone of anime cinema, and that standing is fully deserved. A 9.4 reflects both its towering craft and the storytelling compromises that stop it being flawless.

Read the full review →

Redline

Redline: seven years of hand-drawn speed, spent on one glorious race

Redline is a film with one great idea, which is to draw speed by hand at a level of detail nobody else would attempt, and it commits to that idea so completely that the weaknesses become part of the texture. The story is thin, the middle hour sags, and the characters are silhouettes with good voice actors behind them. None of that stops the opening race and the finale from being some of the most exciting animation ever released, or the film from feeling as fresh as it did at Locarno. It sits in the excellent tier rather than among the essentials because a feature needs more than its set pieces to hold for 102 minutes. As a showcase of what hand-drawn animation can still do, it has hardly been matched.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.