Skip to content

Head to head

Alien: Earth vs Dying for Sex

Dead level: both score 8.6. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Alien: Earth
Alien: Earth

2025 · Excellent

  • The hybrids give the franchise a new question instead of a new monster to run from
  • Sydney Chandler plays a child in an adult body without a single false note
  • Two storylines, corporate drama and creature horror, rarely feel like one show
Cover of Dying for Sex
Dying for Sex

2025 · Excellent

  • Michelle Williams makes Molly prickly, selfish and funny without asking for pity
  • The friendship between Molly and Nikki is the real love story, and it is earned
  • Several of the men around Molly are sketches rather than people

Where the gap is

Craft
9.48.2
Story
8.18.3
Characters
8.68.8
Performances
8.99.4

At a glance

FactAlien: EarthDying for Sex
Released12 August 20254 April 2025
Created byNoah HawleyKim Rosenstock, Liz Meriwether
StarringSydney Chandler, Timothy Olyphant, Alex LawtherMichelle Williams, Jenny Slate, Rob Delaney
NetworkFX (FX on Hulu in the US; Disney+ internationally)FX on Hulu (Disney+ outside the US)
Seasons1 (a second ordered)1 (limited series)
Episodes88
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · ThrillerDrama · Comedy · Black comedy

The two verdicts

Alien: Earth

Alien: Earth — the franchise finally asks who counts as human, and keeps the teeth

*Alien: Earth* is uneven in exactly the way ambitious first seasons tend to be. Its premise is the best the franchise has found since the 1980s, its production design and creature work are worthy of the films it follows, and Sydney Chandler gives the series a centre that no monster could. Against that, the plotting splits into two shows that only intermittently collide, and the middle of the season spends too long telling the audience what it has already understood. The score reflects a series that is excellent in its parts and good as a whole, with every sign that a second season, already ordered, could close the gap.

Read the full review →

Dying for Sex

Dying for Sex: a frank, funny series about wanting things when time is short

Dying for Sex takes a premise that could have been a provocation and turns it into one of the most humane limited series of its year. Its subject is not really sex, or even dying, but the right to want things until the end, and the friendship that makes wanting them bearable. Williams and Slate give performances that will define the show long after its comic set pieces are forgotten. The score stops short of the top tier because the world around the two women is thinner than they are, and because the louder jokes sometimes undercut the quieter truths. It remains a series that treats a real woman's story with candour and affection, and that asks its audience to laugh without ever asking it to look away.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.