Skip to content

Head to head

Alien vs The Shining

Alien takes it by 0.3, 9.6 against 9.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Alien
Alien

1979 · Masterpiece

  • H.R. Giger's creature and derelict designs remain uniquely disturbing
  • Patient pacing builds unbearable, almost physical dread
  • The deliberate first act may test viewers raised on faster horror
Cover of The Shining
The Shining

1980 · Essential

  • Gliding Steadicam shots turn the Overlook's corridors into a maze of dread
  • Jack Nicholson's increasingly unhinged performance is unforgettable
  • Jack's menace is so evident early that his descent has less tragic arc

Where the gap is

Craft
9.99.7
Story
9.08.7
Direction
9.89.8
Performances
9.29.0

At a glance

FactAlienThe Shining
Released22 June 197923 May 1980
DirectorRidley ScottStanley Kubrick
StarringYaphet Kotto, Veronica Cartwright, Tom SkerrittJack Nicholson, Shelley Duvall, Danny Lloyd
Runtime117 minutes146 minutes
Studio20th Century Studios, Brandywine ProductionsHawk Films
GenreSci-Fi · HorrorDrama · Horror

The two verdicts

Alien

Alien: the haunted-house film in deep space that still defines screen horror

Alien is close to a perfect genre film: disciplined, frightening, beautifully designed and anchored by a heroine who rewrote expectations. Its handful of underwritten characters and deliberate opening pace are the only real quibbles. As a landmark of both science fiction and horror, with craft that still looks and sounds superb, it earns a 9.6.

Read the full review →

The Shining

The Shining: Kubrick's cold, labyrinthine horror only grows more unnerving

The Shining is an exceptional, deeply influential horror film, with masterful direction and imagery that has permeated popular culture. Its early portrayal of Jack's instability, thinly written Wendy and deliberate opacity prevent it from being flawless for every viewer. But its hypnotic atmosphere and technical brilliance make it one of the genre's defining films.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.