Skip to content

Head to head

AM vs Currents

Currents takes it by 0.5, 8.7 against 8.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of AM
AM

2013 · Excellent

  • A distinct sound: stomping drums, glam-rock riffs and falsetto backing vocals
  • Alex Turner's lyrics find new, seedy detail in the language of desire
  • The middle stretch repeats the same mid-tempo mood a little too often
Cover of Currents
Currents

2015 · Excellent

  • Production of remarkable depth, made almost entirely by one person
  • Let It Happen is an eight-minute opener that never feels long
  • Parker's reedy, heavily treated voice can feel distant and samey

Where the gap is

Cohesion
7.98.7
Production
8.89.4
Performance
8.48.3
Songwriting
8.38.8

At a glance

FactAMCurrents
Released9 September 201317 July 2015
ArtistArctic MonkeysTame Impala
LabelDomino Recording CompanyInterscope Records, Interscope Records
Tracks1213
Length41:3251:13
GenreAlternative rock · RockAlternative rock · Electronic · Pop

The two verdicts

AM

AM: Arctic Monkeys trade Sheffield wit for a slow, smoky late-night swagger

AM is an excellent reinvention with clear flaws. The production and the rhythm section give it an identity strong enough to shape a generation of guitar bands, and its best songs are among the most recognisable rock of the 2010s. A sagging middle and a persona that occasionally feels like a costume hold it to an 8.2: a very good album that is sometimes more about attitude than depth.

Read the full review →

Currents

Currents: Kevin Parker swaps fuzz for synths and writes a lush, sad breakup epic

Currents scores 8.7 as an excellent, era-defining album with a few clear limits. The production is extraordinary for a largely solo effort, the songwriting is more honest than anything Parker had attempted before, and its influence reaches far beyond indie rock. A distant vocal presence and a few filler interludes stop it reaching the very top tier, but it remains the essential Tame Impala record.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.