Skip to content

Head to head

American Gods vs Mistborn: The Final Empire

Dead level: both score 8.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of American Gods
American Gods

2001 · Excellent

  • A brilliant central conceit: gods that survive only as long as belief does
  • Roadside America rendered with an outsider's affectionate, eerie eye
  • Shadow's passivity leaves long stretches without a driving pulse
Cover of Mistborn: The Final Empire
  • Allomancy's rules are clear, clever and thrilling in combat
  • Framing an uprising as a heist gives the plot energy and wit
  • Functional prose rarely rises beyond clarity

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.18.7
Story
7.58.6
Writing
8.47.0
Characters
7.88.0

At a glance

FactAmerican GodsMistborn: The Final Empire
Released19 June 200117 July 2006
AuthorNeil GaimanBrandon Sanderson
PublisherWilliam MorrowTor Books
Pages465541
GenreFantasy · Literary fictionAdventure · Fantasy

The two verdicts

American Gods

American Gods: a sprawling road trip through a country's forgotten faiths

American Gods is an imaginative, generous, frequently beautiful novel whose sprawl works against it as often as for it. The ideas and interludes are first-rate, Wednesday is unforgettable, and the portrait of the American backroads is distinctive. A passive lead and a sagging middle stop it from being the masterpiece its concept promises, but it remains an excellent, singular fantasy.

Read the full review →

Mistborn: The Final Empire

Mistborn: The Final Empire: a fantasy heist built on a brilliantly logical magic

Mistborn: The Final Empire succeeds through ingenuity and structure: an original magic system, an irresistible heist premise and a payoff built on meticulous foreshadowing. Plain prose, a sagging middle and underwritten antagonists hold it back from greatness, but it remains an excellent, highly enjoyable fantasy that has earned its enduring popularity.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.