Skip to content

Head to head

American Gods vs The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle

The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle takes it by 0.6, 8.7 against 8.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of American Gods
American Gods

2001 · Excellent

  • A brilliant central conceit: gods that survive only as long as belief does
  • Roadside America rendered with an outsider's affectionate, eerie eye
  • Shadow's passivity leaves long stretches without a driving pulse
Cover of The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle
  • Blends suburban ennui with dreamlike mystery to remarkable effect
  • Lieutenant Mamiya's war story is one of Murakami's most powerful passages
  • Many plot threads and symbols are left unresolved

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.19.2
Story
7.58.1
Writing
8.48.8
Characters
7.88.5

At a glance

FactAmerican GodsThe Wind-Up Bird Chronicle
Released19 June 20011994
AuthorNeil GaimanHaruki Murakami
PublisherWilliam MorrowShinchosha, Vintage Books
Pages465607
GenreFantasy · Literary fictionFantasy · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

American Gods

American Gods: a sprawling road trip through a country's forgotten faiths

American Gods is an imaginative, generous, frequently beautiful novel whose sprawl works against it as often as for it. The ideas and interludes are first-rate, Wednesday is unforgettable, and the portrait of the American backroads is distinctive. A passive lead and a sagging middle stop it from being the masterpiece its concept promises, but it remains an excellent, singular fantasy.

Read the full review →

The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle

The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle: Murakami's darkest, deepest and most sprawling novel

The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle is a haunting, profound and imaginatively rich novel that stands among Murakami's most significant works. Its unresolved threads, digressive structure and harrowing violence make it demanding, and it can feel shapeless, but its depth, atmosphere and historical power make it an excellent and unforgettable read.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.