Skip to content

Head to head

Banana Fish vs Land of the Lustrous

Land of the Lustrous takes it by 0.6, 8.4 against 7.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Banana Fish
Banana Fish

2018 · Good

  • The Ash and Eiji relationship is written with real tenderness and restraint
  • Treats trauma and abuse as lasting wounds rather than plot decoration
  • The middle stretch repeats a capture, escape and recapture pattern too often
Cover of Land of the Lustrous
Land of the Lustrous

2017 · Excellent

  • Refractive, glittering gem bodies show CG animation at its most expressive
  • Phos's transformation raises real questions about identity and self
  • Adapts only an early portion of the manga, with no continuation so far

Where the gap is

Sound
7.98.4
Story
7.48.3
Animation
7.29.2
Characters
8.68.5

At a glance

FactBanana FishLand of the Lustrous
Released6 July 20187 October 2017
StudioMAPPAOrange
DirectorHiroko UtsumiTakahiko Kyōgoku
Episodes2412
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreAction · Drama · SuspenseAction · Drama · Fantasy

The two verdicts

Banana Fish

Banana Fish: a harrowing crime saga held together by one fragile bond

Banana Fish is powered by one of the most affecting central relationships in recent anime, and its handling of trauma gives it a weight many thrillers lack. Repetitive plotting, sagging animation and cartoonish antagonists hold it back from greatness. It was warmly received, especially by viewers invested in its leads, and a 7.8 reflects a good, sometimes excellent series with clear and recurring flaws.

Read the full review →

Land of the Lustrous

Land of the Lustrous proves CG anime can be breathtaking, strange and profound

Land of the Lustrous is a visually dazzling and emotionally rich fantasy that pushed the boundaries of CG animation. Its slow opening, limited adaptation and occasional stiffness are notable weaknesses. It earned strong acclaim among critics and fans who discovered it, and an 8.4 reflects an excellent, distinctive series with clear flaws.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.