Skip to content

Head to head

Batman: Year One vs Sin City

Batman: Year One takes it by 1.1, 9.1 against 8.0. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Batman: Year One
Batman: Year One

1987 · Essential

  • Mazzucchelli's restrained, economical linework is a masterclass in clarity
  • Gives Jim Gordon a full, flawed arc equal to Bruce Wayne's
  • Selina Kyle's rewritten backstory is thinly sketched and dated
Cover of Sin City
Sin City

1991 · Excellent

  • Miller's high-contrast art is a genuine landmark of comics design
  • Marv's story in The Hard Goodbye is a ferocious, propulsive thriller
  • Women are largely reduced to sex workers, femmes fatales or victims

Where the gap is

Art
9.49.5
Story
9.07.4
Pacing
9.08.2
Characters
9.27.3

At a glance

FactBatman: Year OneSin City
Released1 February 19871 April 1991
WriterFrank MillerFrank Miller
PublisherDC ComicsDark Horse Comics
Issues47
GenreNoir · Superhero · CrimeNoir · Graphic Novel · Crime

The two verdicts

Batman: Year One

Batman: Year One strips the legend back to two tired men and a corrupt city

Year One is close to a perfect short graphic novel: focused, beautifully drawn and built on characters rather than spectacle. Its handling of Selina Kyle is thin and its compression leaves a few gaps, but those are small complaints against a book that redefined how Batman's origin is told. A 9.1 recognises a genuine classic that has lost almost none of its force.

Read the full review →

Sin City

Sin City pushes noir to pure black and white, brilliantly and without restraint

Sin City is a stunning visual achievement with a handful of genuinely gripping crime stories, especially The Hard Goodbye. Its reductive treatment of women, self-parodic writing and diminishing returns in later volumes keep it from greatness as storytelling. An 8.0 reflects an excellent, influential work whose art far outstrips its ideas.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.