Skip to content

Head to head

Battlestar Galactica vs Dark

Dead level: both score 8.9. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Battlestar Galactica
Battlestar Galactica

2004 · Excellent

  • The first two seasons turn every supply shortage and election into a moral test
  • Olmos and McDonnell make the military–civilian split feel personal, not schematic
  • The mythology outgrows the plotting in the last two seasons
Cover of Dark
Dark

2017 · Excellent

  • A genuinely coherent time-travel plot planned from start to finish
  • Casting across age groups makes the generations instantly readable
  • The sheer number of timelines demands notes and occasional rewatching

Where the gap is

Craft
9.09.2
Story
8.49.3
Characters
9.38.3
Performances
9.48.6

At a glance

FactBattlestar GalacticaDark
Released18 October 20041 December 2017
Created byGlen A. Larson, Ronald D. MooreBaran Bo Odar, Jantje Friese
StarringEdward James Olmos, Mary McDonnell, Katee SackhoffLouis Hofmann, Oliver Masucci, Maja Schöne
NetworkSci Fi Channel (now Syfy); Sky One in the UKNetflix
Seasons4 (plus the 2003 miniseries)3
Episodes74 (plus the two-part miniseries and the TV films Razor and The Plan)26
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · WarSci-Fi · Drama · Mystery

The two verdicts

Battlestar Galactica

Battlestar Galactica: the war drama that made space opera argue about politics

Battlestar Galactica earns its reputation on the strength of what it made ordinary: serious political drama in a space setting, a central partnership between a soldier and a civilian that never resolves into easy agreement, and a production style that much later science fiction borrowed. The first two seasons are close to flawless, and the performances by Olmos, McDonnell, Sackhoff and Callis hold even the weaker episodes together. The score stops short of the essential tier because the series, having promised a plan, does not always seem to have one: the third season sags in the middle, the fourth leans on mythology at the expense of the political story, and the finale remains contested. Those are real faults in a show that is still required viewing for anyone who cares about the genre.

Read the full review →

Dark

Dark: a time-travel puzzle box that actually knows where it is going

Dark scores 8.9 because it achieves something very difficult: a time-travel story of enormous scope that holds together logically and pays off emotionally. Its complexity can feel punishing, its tone is unrelentingly grave and some characters are more mechanism than person, but as an exercise in planned, puzzle-driven storytelling it has few equals on television.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.