Skip to content

Head to head

Beloved vs The Great Gatsby

Dead level: both score 9.3. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Beloved
Beloved

1987 · Essential

  • Prose of extraordinary density, rhythm and emotional force
  • Sethe, Paul D and Denver are complex, contradictory, fully human
  • Deliberately withheld information makes early chapters disorienting
Cover of The Great Gatsby
The Great Gatsby

1925 · Essential

  • Some of the most precise, lyrical prose in American literature
  • Gatsby's green light and the valley of ashes are indelible images
  • Daisy remains more an object of longing than a fully realised woman

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.69.3
Story
8.78.8
Writing
9.89.8
Characters
9.48.6

At a glance

FactBelovedThe Great Gatsby
Released16 September 198710 April 1925
AuthorToni MorrisonF. Scott Fitzgerald
PublisherAlfred A. KnopfCharles Scribner's Sons
Pages324180
GenreDrama · Literary fiction · HistoryDrama · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

Beloved

Beloved: Toni Morrison's ghost story makes the unbearable impossible to look away from

Beloved is a towering novel whose difficulty is inseparable from its greatness. Its structure disorients by design, and a few passages are more opaque than they need to be, which is why it stops just short of a perfect mark here. But its characters, language and moral seriousness are extraordinary, and its reckoning with memory and slavery has lost none of its force since its Pulitzer-winning release.

Read the full review →

The Great Gatsby

The Great Gatsby: a short, shimmering novel that keeps revealing new depths

The Great Gatsby is a nearly flawless novel whose prose, structure and imagery remain astonishing a century after publication. An underwritten Daisy and some dated caricatures prevent a perfect mark, but its portrait of longing and self-invention is profound and endlessly suggestive. It is an exceptional, essential book.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.