Skip to content

Head to head

Bicycle Thieves vs Pulp Fiction

Dead level: both score 9.5. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Bicycle Thieves
Bicycle Thieves

1948 · Masterpiece

  • A plot no bigger than one bicycle, which lets every scene carry the whole economy
  • Enzo Staiola's Bruno watches his father, and the film lets the audience watch him do it
  • Alessandro Cicognini's score pushes for tears the images have already earned
Cover of Pulp Fiction
Pulp Fiction

1994 · Masterpiece

  • Dialogue so rhythmic and funny that whole exchanges became part of pop culture
  • Non-linear structure turns a set of crime stories into something surprising
  • Casual, repeated use of racial slurs sits badly and grates today

Where the gap is

Craft
9.09.3
Story
9.39.4
Direction
9.89.6
Performances
9.69.5

At a glance

FactBicycle ThievesPulp Fiction
Released24 November 194814 October 1994
DirectorVittorio De SicaQuentin Tarantino
StarringLamberto Maggiorani, Enzo Staiola, Lianella CarellBruce Willis, John Travolta, Rosanna Arquette
Runtime89 minutes154 minutes
StudioProduzioni De SicaA Band Apart, Jersey Films
GenreDrama · NeorealismDrama · Crime

The two verdicts

Bicycle Thieves

Bicycle Thieves: a small theft that still carries the weight of a whole city

*Bicycle Thieves* earns its reputation the hard way, by doing something simple without a false step. One stolen bicycle opens on to a whole society, and the film never raises its voice to make the point; it trusts a pawnshop shelf, a wet market and a boy watching his father to do it. The performances by people who had never acted are still among the most convincing in cinema, and De Sica's direction has the patience of someone who knew exactly what he was looking at. The score is a period compromise and the post-dubbed dialogue occasionally shows, which keeps it a fraction below perfect. Neither touches what matters. More than seventy-five years on, it remains the first film to show anyone who asks where realist cinema begins, and one of the few landmarks that still plays as a story rather than a lesson.

Read the full review →

Pulp Fiction

Pulp Fiction: the talky, time-scrambled crime film that rewired the nineties

Pulp Fiction is a landmark: a film that changed how stories could be structured and dialogue could be written in mainstream cinema, and one that still delivers on every level of craft and performance. Its gratuitous slurs and some queasy choices keep it from a perfect score, but its invention, wit and enduring energy place it firmly among the defining films of its medium.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.