Skip to content

Head to head

Birds of a Feather vs Yesterday

Dead level: both score 8.9. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Birds of a Feather
Birds of a Feather

2024 · Excellent

  • A chorus that lands on the second listen and never leaves
  • The arrangement stays light enough for the lyric to do the damage
  • The verses are sketchy next to the hook they set up
Cover of Yesterday
Yesterday

1965 · Excellent

  • A melody so natural it feels as though it has always existed
  • The spare string quartet arrangement adds poignancy without excess
  • Its brevity leaves little room for musical development

Where the gap is

Production
9.08.7
Performance
9.28.9
Songwriting
8.79.5
Replay value
9.08.2

At a glance

FactBirds of a FeatherYesterday
Released17 May 202413 September 1965
ArtistBillie EilishThe Beatles, Marianne Faithfull
AlbumHIT ME HARD AND SOFTHelp!
LabelInterscope Records, Darkroom—
Length3:302:05
GenrePop · Synth pop · Indie popPop · Rock

The two verdicts

Birds of a Feather

Birds of a Feather: the plainest song she has written, and the heaviest

A song this ubiquitous invites suspicion, and "Birds of a Feather" survives it. The writing is not the most ambitious on its album and the verses are plainly the weakest part of it, but the chorus is one of the few in recent pop that improves with familiarity rather than wearing through, and the final minute is the best singing on any Eilish record. Finneas deserves as much of the credit: he built a bright, thin, unhurried arrangement and then refused every chance to decorate it, which is why a lyric about devotion with no exit still reads as a lyric rather than a production. It falls short of the top tier for its writing, not its effect. On effect alone it is untouchable.

Read the full review →

Yesterday

Yesterday: Paul McCartney, a guitar and four strings make the perfect lament

Yesterday earns an 8.9. McCartney's melody is close to flawless, and the decision to strip the arrangement back to voice, guitar and strings was quietly radical for The Beatles in 1965. Its brevity and plain lyric keep it a step behind the band's most ambitious songs, but as a lesson in economy, it is hard to better.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.