Skip to content

Head to head

Blue vs Illmatic

Dead level: both score 9.6. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Blue
Blue

1971 · Masterpiece

  • Ten songs with no filler, each built around a single, precisely observed situation
  • The dulcimer gives the record a sound no other singer-songwriter album of 1971 has
  • The high, fluttering soprano and its vibrato are an acquired taste for some listeners
Cover of Illmatic
Illmatic

1994 · Masterpiece

  • Ten tracks with no filler, no skits and no crossover bid
  • N.Y. State of Mind keeps a false start in, then never slips again
  • Hooks are scratched slogans, so almost nothing here is singable

Where the gap is

Cohesion
9.59.7
Production
8.99.6
Performance
9.79.5
Songwriting
9.99.8

At a glance

FactBlueIllmatic
Released22 June 197119 April 1994
ArtistJoni MitchellNas
LabelReprise RecordsColumbia Records
Tracks1010
Length35:3939:48
GenreFolk rock · Folk · Singer songwriterHip-hop · Jazz

The two verdicts

Blue

Blue: ten songs that turned candour into a craft, and still sound unguarded

*Blue* earns its place near the top of any list of great albums because it does something difficult with apparent ease: it makes specific, private experience sound both exact and universal, without decoration to hide behind. The songwriting is close to flawless, the performances are unrepeatable in the best sense, and the sequencing gives ten separate songs the shape of a single story. The score stops short of perfect for two honest reasons. The voice that makes the record for many listeners will keep others at a distance, and the bareness that gives it power also makes the slower stretch of the second side less varied than the first. Neither changes the conclusion. Few records have been so influential, and fewer still remain as alive on the hundredth listen as on the first.

Read the full review →

Illmatic

Illmatic: ten tracks, thirty-nine minutes, and nothing spare

The score reflects a record that does one thing and leaves nothing on the floor. Ten tracks, five producers and a single method — dry drums under a looped jazz or soul figure, verses built from observed detail rather than assertion — produce forty minutes with no weak passage and two or three of the finest performances rap has recorded. It is held just short of a perfect mark by an opening track that is atmosphere rather than song, by a narrowness of register that is inseparable from the achievement, and by an original master that does the beats no favours. Those are small charges against an album that has never needed its reputation to justify itself.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.