Skip to content

Head to head

Blue vs Rumours

Blue takes it by 0.1, 9.6 against 9.5. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Blue
Blue

1971 · Masterpiece

  • Ten songs with no filler, each built around a single, precisely observed situation
  • The dulcimer gives the record a sound no other singer-songwriter album of 1971 has
  • The high, fluttering soprano and its vibrato are an acquired taste for some listeners
Cover of Rumours
Rumours

1977 · Masterpiece

  • Three writers with three distinct voices, each on top form within the same forty minutes
  • Harmonies stacked so closely that Buckingham, Nicks and McVie sound like one throat
  • Christine McVie's "Oh Daddy" is the one track that drifts rather than lands

Where the gap is

Cohesion
9.59.2
Production
8.99.6
Performance
9.79.4
Songwriting
9.99.7

At a glance

FactBlueRumours
Released22 June 19714 February 1977
ArtistJoni MitchellFleetwood Mac
LabelReprise RecordsWarner Bros. Records, Big Brother Recordings
Tracks1011
Length35:3939:03
GenreFolk rock · Folk · Singer songwriterRock · Pop rock · Soft rock

The two verdicts

Blue

Blue: ten songs that turned candour into a craft, and still sound unguarded

*Blue* earns its place near the top of any list of great albums because it does something difficult with apparent ease: it makes specific, private experience sound both exact and universal, without decoration to hide behind. The songwriting is close to flawless, the performances are unrepeatable in the best sense, and the sequencing gives ten separate songs the shape of a single story. The score stops short of perfect for two honest reasons. The voice that makes the record for many listeners will keep others at a distance, and the bareness that gives it power also makes the slower stretch of the second side less varied than the first. Neither changes the conclusion. Few records have been so influential, and fewer still remain as alive on the hundredth listen as on the first.

Read the full review →

Rumours

Rumours: five people falling apart, and eleven songs that never once sound like it

Rumours earns its place among the landmarks of popular music not because of the story behind it but because of how completely the songs absorb that story. Three writers in different states of heartbreak each produced the best work of their careers, and a rhythm section and two producers shaped it into a record so even that its darkest moments slip past on a first listen. The score is held just short of perfect by a single soft track and by a smoothness that some listeners will always hear as a limitation. Everyone else will hear what millions have heard since 1977: a band at its lowest, sounding as good as any band has ever sounded.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.