Skip to content

Head to head

Challengers vs Marcel the Shell with Shoes On

Dead level: both score 8.0. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Challengers
Challengers

2024 · Excellent

  • All three leads create a volatile, magnetic chemistry
  • Josh O'Connor is a scene-stealing mix of charm and self-sabotage
  • The constant flashback structure becomes a little mechanical
Cover of Marcel the Shell with Shoes On
  • Jenny Slate's voice work makes Marcel funny, wise and fragile
  • Isabella Rossellini brings great warmth to Nana Connie
  • The gentle, whimsical tone may feel twee to some viewers

Where the gap is

Craft
8.38.6
Story
7.87.4
Direction
8.58.2
Performances
8.48.8

At a glance

FactChallengersMarcel the Shell with Shoes On
Released26 April 202424 June 2022
DirectorLuca GuadagninoDean Fleischer Camp
StarringZendaya, Mike Faist, Josh O'Connor—
Runtime131 minutes89 minutes
StudioPascal Pictures, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer—
GenreDrama · Romance · SportsDrama · Comedy · Animation

The two verdicts

Challengers

Challengers: a sweaty, electric love triangle played as a tennis match

Challengers is energetic, sexy and inventively directed, powered by three excellent performances and a thumping score. The flashback structure grows repetitive and Tashi remains more concept than character, which keeps it from greatness. As a smart and entertaining adult drama that finds new life in a familiar love triangle, it earns an 8.0.

Read the full review →

Marcel the Shell with Shoes On

Marcel the Shell with Shoes On: a tiny film with a surprisingly enormous heart

Marcel the Shell with Shoes On is a small miracle of a film, tender, funny and quietly wise, with outstanding voice performances and inventive animation. Its slight plot and whimsical style will not suit everyone, and some ideas feel underdeveloped. For those who fall under its spell, it is a lasting joy, and it earns an 8.0.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.