Skip to content

Head to head

Comfortably Numb vs Hurt

Dead level: both score 9.2. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Comfortably Numb
Comfortably Numb

1979 · Essential

  • David Gilmour's closing solo is a masterclass in melody and tone
  • The contrast between Waters' flat verses and Gilmour's soaring choruses
  • Its slow tempo and six-minute length can feel heavy on its own
Cover of Hurt
Hurt

2002 · Essential

  • A vocal that makes age and frailty part of the meaning rather than a flaw
  • Rubin keeps the arrangement to guitars and piano until the last minute
  • So heavy that it rarely suits a casual listen, and is hard to hear twice in a row

Where the gap is

Production
9.19.2
Performance
9.69.8
Songwriting
9.39.6
Replay value
8.88.2

At a glance

FactComfortably NumbHurt
Released30 November 19795 November 2002
ArtistPink Floyd, Scissor SistersJohnny Cash, Juice Newton
AlbumThe WallAmerican IV: The Man Comes Around
Length6:233:38
GenreProgressive rock · RockCountry · Gothic country · Acoustic rock
Label—American Recordings

The two verdicts

Comfortably Numb

Comfortably Numb: Pink Floyd's bleakest ballad and the solo that crowns it

A 9.2 reflects a song in which two very different writers pulled in the same direction for six minutes, with one of rock's most admired solos as the payoff. It would sit higher still if it did not lean so heavily on The Wall's story for its full effect, and if the orchestra did not occasionally swell a little too far.

Read the full review →

Hurt

Hurt: a young man's confession, sung back by a man with no time left

The score rests on a performance that could only have happened once. A great song, written by someone else for another purpose, met a singer whose life had already lived out its subject, at the one moment when his voice could carry it and no later. Rubin's arrangement steps out of the way, and the single changed image in the second verse proves Cash understood exactly what he was doing with the material. It falls short of a perfect mark for two reasons. It is so heavy that it is hard to return to often. And it now leans on the video and on the deaths that followed it. Even so, it is one of the few recordings that justify the cliché about a cover becoming its own song: its writer said so himself.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.