Skip to content

Head to head

Crazy in Love vs Dancing on My Own

Dancing on My Own takes it by 0.3, 9.1 against 8.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Crazy in Love
Crazy in Love

2003 · Excellent

  • The Chi-Lites horn sample is one of pop's great opening fanfares
  • Beyoncé's vocal is agile, commanding and full of joy
  • Jay-Z's opening verse is serviceable rather than memorable
Cover of Dancing on My Own
Dancing on My Own

2010 · Essential

  • A chorus that works as a dance-floor release and a confession at once
  • A bare, hammering synth bass that leaves room for every word in the verses
  • The vocal is deliberately controlled, so some may want more raw edge

Where the gap is

Production
9.39.2
Performance
9.38.8
Songwriting
8.59.4
Replay value
9.09.2

At a glance

FactCrazy in LoveDancing on My Own
Released18 May 200320 April 2010
ArtistBeyonce, Jay-ZRobyn
AlbumDangerously in LoveBody Talk Pt. 1
LabelColumbia RecordsKonichiwa Records
Length3:564:48
GenrePop · R&BPop · Synth pop · Electropop

The two verdicts

Crazy in Love

Crazy in Love: Beyoncé's solo launch, powered by the horns heard around the world

Crazy in Love gets an 8.8. Rich Harrison's use of the Chi-Lites horns and Beyoncé's electric vocal make it one of the most exciting opening statements any solo career has had. The lyrics are thin and the Jay-Z verse feels like a marketing decision, which is why it falls short of the 9s, but two decades on, the first blast of brass still does its job.

Read the full review →

Dancing on My Own

Dancing on My Own: the saddest song ever built to be danced to

"Dancing on My Own" is one of the best pop singles of its decade, and it is worth four minutes of anyone's time, whether they know Robyn or not. The writing is plain and exact, the production is hard and spare, and the combination of a bleak story with an unstoppable beat is handled with a control few songs manage. It sits just short of the very top tier because the vocal is deliberately held back, the radio edit softens what the album version does best, and its reputation as the definitive "sad banger" sometimes covers how quiet and careful it really is. Those are small complaints. For the dance floor, for headphones, or for walking home alone, this is a song to keep.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.