Skip to content

Head to head

Creep vs Paranoid Android

Paranoid Android takes it by 1.5, 9.3 against 7.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Creep
Creep

1992 · Good

  • Thom Yorke's vocal rises from fragile murmur to a raw, soaring cry
  • Jonny Greenwood's crunching guitar bursts give the chorus real bite
  • Its chord progression and melody lean heavily on an older hit
Cover of Paranoid Android
Paranoid Android

1997 · Essential

  • Distinct sections flow together with startling, dramatic logic
  • Jonny Greenwood's guitar outbursts are ferocious and inventive
  • Abrupt transitions can feel jarring before the song becomes familiar

Where the gap is

Production
7.29.3
Performance
8.59.4
Songwriting
7.69.4
Replay value
7.98.9

At a glance

FactCreepParanoid Android
Released21 September 199226 May 1997
ArtistRadioheadRadiohead
AlbumPablo HoneyOK Computer
LabelParlophoneParlophone
Length3:566:23
GenreAlternative rockAlternative rock · Art rock

The two verdicts

Creep

Creep: the outsider anthem Radiohead outgrew but never quite escaped

Creep lands at 7.8. Yorke's vocal and Greenwood's guitar bursts give it real force, and its outsider theme has kept it alive for decades. Its derivative foundations, simple lyrics and dated production mark it as an early step rather than a peak, but as an anthem of self-doubt, it still hits hard.

Read the full review →

Paranoid Android

Paranoid Android: Radiohead stitch three songs into a six-minute breakdown

Paranoid Android earns a 9.3. It crams more ideas into six minutes than most bands manage across an album, and the choral lament at its centre is among the most beautiful passages Radiohead have recorded. The abrupt transitions and elusive lyrics keep it just short of perfect, but it remains the purest distillation of what made OK Computer so startling.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.