Skip to content

Head to head

The Dark Forest vs The Three-Body Problem

The Dark Forest takes it by 0.6, 8.5 against 7.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Dark Forest
The Dark Forest

2008 · Excellent

  • The Wallfacer premise turns secrecy into a gripping strategic puzzle
  • Its central theory of cosmic civilisations is chilling and memorable
  • Luo Ji's idealised romance subplot is awkward and dated
Cover of The Three-Body Problem
  • Its opening Cultural Revolution scenes are powerful and historically grounded
  • The three-suns game is a brilliant device for exploring alien physics
  • Wang Miao is a bland protagonist with little inner life

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.79.5
Story
8.87.8
Writing
7.57.0
Characters
6.96.5

At a glance

FactThe Dark ForestThe Three-Body Problem
Released1 May 20082008
AuthorLiu CixinLiu Cixin
PublisherChongqing Publishing GroupChongqing Publishing Group
Pages400400
GenreSci-FiSci-Fi

The two verdicts

The Dark Forest

The Dark Forest: Liu Cixin's bleak cosmic chess game outdoes its predecessor

The Dark Forest is a bigger, bolder and better-constructed book than its predecessor, driven by a superb premise and a truly haunting central idea. Flat characters, a clumsy romantic thread and stiff exposition keep it from greatness on every front, but as a work of speculative imagination it is exceptional, and it lifts the whole trilogy with it.

Read the full review →

The Three-Body Problem

The Three-Body Problem: huge, dizzying ideas carried by a slow, stiff opening act

The Three-Body Problem is a bold and intellectually thrilling novel whose ideas and historical grounding make it a significant work of modern science fiction. Flat characters, heavy exposition and an uneven middle keep it from greatness as a novel. It is a good, sometimes remarkable read with notable issues, and an essential opening to a larger saga.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.