Skip to content

Head to head

Deadwood vs The Pitt

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Deadwood
Deadwood

2004 · Essential

  • Dialogue that braids profanity and ornate syntax into a language of its own
  • Ian McShane makes a murderous saloon keeper the most persuasive mind in town
  • The opening episodes demand patience before the speech rhythms start to click
Cover of The Pitt
The Pitt

2025 · Essential

  • Fifteen hourly episodes with no time jump and no scene away from the department
  • Procedure staged for accuracy at the edge of frame, reactions held in close-up
  • Thirty near-identical hours flatten several residents into their reflexes

Where the gap is

Craft
9.39.5
Story
8.68.8
Characters
9.69.2
Performances
9.79.4

At a glance

FactDeadwoodThe Pitt
Released21 March 20049 January 2025
Created byDavid MilchR. Scott Gemmill
StarringTimothy Olyphant, Ian McShane, Molly ParkerNoah Wyle, Tracy Ifeachor, Patrick Ball
NetworkHBOHBO Max (Max)
Seasons3, plus a 2019 film2 (a third ordered)
Episodes3630
GenreDrama · Western · HistoricalDrama · Medical · Procedural

The two verdicts

Deadwood

Deadwood: the western that found Shakespeare in a mud street, and was cut off mid-sentence

Deadwood is one of the most distinctive dramas television has produced: a western that replaces the gunfight with the negotiation, and finds in a muddy gold camp a study of how civilisation is improvised by people with no interest in civilising anyone. Its language and its ensemble, led by Ian McShane, are as good as the medium gets, and the camp itself is a triumph of design. The score stops short of the very top because the series was not allowed to finish what it started, and because its later plotting sprawls in ways the cancellation exposed rather than caused. The 2019 film repairs much of the damage. Taken whole, it is essential viewing for anyone who cares what television can do with words.

Read the full review →

The Pitt

The Pitt: one shift, fifteen hours and nowhere for anyone to hide

*The Pitt* took the most worked-over setting on television and found a real formal idea in it: hold the clock, refuse the cutaway, and let one shift accumulate. Everything else follows from that — the staging in the background, the missing score, exhaustion arriving on screen at roughly the hour it would arrive in life. Wyle gives the most sustained work of his career, and the ensemble around him is cast and drilled to the standard the format demands. It falls short of the very top because thirty near-identical hours flatten some of its people into their reflexes, and because its case against a broken health system is made far more often than it is developed. As construction, though, it has few rivals currently running, and it has earned what it has been given.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.