Skip to content

Head to head

Despacito vs Nuvole Bianche

Nuvole Bianche takes it by 0.1, 8.3 against 8.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Despacito
Despacito

2017 · Excellent

  • The cuatro intro announces Puerto Rico in four seconds, before a word is sung
  • A pre-chorus that slows down when every other hit would speed up
  • Ubiquity in 2017 wore the song thin, and repeat plays show the seams
Cover of Nuvole Bianche
Nuvole Bianche

2004 · Excellent

  • A melody simple enough to hum after one hearing, and sturdy enough to survive the hundredth
  • The climb from near-silence to full chords is paced with real patience
  • The harmony barely moves, and listeners who want development will hear a loop

Where the gap is

Production
8.77.6
Performance
8.38.2
Songwriting
8.48.5
Replay value
7.48.9

At a glance

FactDespacitoNuvole Bianche
Released13 January 20176 September 2004
ArtistLuis Fonsi, Daddy YankeeLudovico Einaudi
AlbumVidaUna Mattina (track 12 of 13)
LabelUniversal Music LatinoDecca Records
Length3:475:58
GenrePop · Reggaeton · LatinContemporary classical · Minimalism · Instrumental

The two verdicts

Despacito

Despacito: a crooner's ballad in reggaeton clothes that taught the world to wait for the drop

"Despacito" is better than its reputation and slightly worse than its numbers. The writing is shrewd rather than deep, built around one great idea, a chorus that arrives by slowing down, and the production is a model of saying a lot with very little, from the cuatro to the empty bars before the drop. Daddy Yankee's verse turns a polished pop song into a party without losing its manners. What holds the score in the low eights is the record's afterlife: the overplay was real, the remix diluted what made the original distinct, and the lyric does not reward close attention. As the song that carried Spanish-language pop to the top of the world's charts, it is essential; as a record to play on repeat, it asks for some distance first.

Read the full review →

Nuvole Bianche

Nuvole Bianche: six minutes of piano that do very little, on purpose, and very well

Nuvole Bianche earns its place through proportion rather than invention. Einaudi takes a melody of a few notes and a chord cycle that never strays, and paces their repetition so precisely that the piece seems to breathe rather than loop. The score reflects that achievement and its limits: the harmony is static by design, the climax relies on weight more than on a new idea, and the recording is plain enough to sound slightly hard at full volume. Those reservations are real, and listeners who need music to argue with them will stay unconvinced. For everyone else it remains one of the clearest arguments for doing very little with great care, and the reason so many people first arrived at contemporary piano music at all.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.