Skip to content

Head to head

Do I Wanna Know? vs New Person, Same Old Mistakes

Do I Wanna Know? takes it by 0.2, 8.1 against 7.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Do I Wanna Know?
Do I Wanna Know?

2013 · Excellent

  • A stalking, hypnotic guitar riff that is instantly recognisable
  • The stomping, hand-clap-heavy beat gives it a heavy, deliberate swagger
  • Its slow, repetitive structure can drag over four and a half minutes
Cover of New Person, Same Old Mistakes
  • A heavy, lurching groove that feels unusually physical for Tame Impala
  • Dense synth layers give the track an immersive, enveloping sound
  • Its slow tempo and six-minute length can feel sluggish in isolation

Where the gap is

Production
8.78.9
Performance
8.37.6
Songwriting
8.08.0
Replay value
8.67.7

At a glance

FactDo I Wanna Know?New Person, Same Old Mistakes
Released18 June 201317 July 2015
ArtistArctic MonkeysTame Impala
AlbumAMCurrents
LabelDomino Recording CompanyInterscope Records
Length4:326:03
GenreAlternative rock · RockAlternative rock · Electronic

The two verdicts

Do I Wanna Know?

Do I Wanna Know?: Arctic Monkeys' slow, heavy riff built for late-night longing

An 8.1 recognises a riff and a drum pattern that became a template for guitar bands in the 2010s, and a late-night mood captured with real precision. The song's static shape and a lyric that circles rather than develops keep it a notch below the band's sharpest writing.

Read the full review →

New Person, Same Old Mistakes

New Person, Same Old Mistakes: Tame Impala close Currents with a heavy, honest shrug

New Person, Same Old Mistakes earns a 7.9. Its production is dense and assured, and as a closing statement it gives Currents a thoughtful, unresolved ending. As a standalone song it is slower and murkier than the album's best tracks, and its central argument is sometimes hard to hear through the effects.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.