Skip to content

Head to head

Educated vs The House of the Spirits

Dead level: both score 8.3. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Educated
Educated

2018 · Excellent

  • Scrapyard and mountainside scenes are vivid, frightening and precise
  • Treats a loving yet dangerous family with complexity, not caricature
  • Repeated episodes of violence start to blur into a pattern by the midpoint
Cover of The House of the Spirits
The House of the Spirits

1982 · Excellent

  • Clara del Valle is an enchanting, unforgettable presence
  • Blends family drama and political history into a gripping sweep
  • Its magical realism owes a heavy and obvious debt to García Márquez

Where the gap is

Ideas
8.08.2
Story
8.78.3
Writing
8.58.5
Characters
8.38.6

At a glance

FactEducatedThe House of the Spirits
Released20 February 20181982
AuthorTara WestoverIsabel Allende
PublisherRandom HouseSudamericana
Pages334433
GenreNon-fiction · BiopicDrama · Magical realism · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

Educated

Educated: Tara Westover's memoir of escape is gripping and quietly devastating

Educated is a compelling and courageous memoir that avoids easy triumphalism and treats its subject, and its family, with notable nuance. A repetitive middle and a rushed final third keep it from the top rank of the form, and it should be read as one person's account, but its portrait of what learning can give and take away is powerful and lingers.

Read the full review →

The House of the Spirits

The House of the Spirits: Isabel Allende's family saga turns magic into witness

The House of the Spirits is an ambitious, absorbing debut that combines magical storytelling with a searing account of political violence. Its derivative early style, uneven tone and difficult central figure hold it back from the very highest ranks, but its characters, especially Clara and Alba, and its commitment to memory and witness make it an excellent and moving novel.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.