Skip to content

Head to head

Elden Ring Nightreign vs Stellar Blade

Dead level: both score 7.8. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Elden Ring Nightreign
  • Sprinting, wall-jumps and no fall damage turn Limgrave's old fields into a racetrack
  • Fixed heroes with ultimate arts give each of the three seats a distinct job
  • Solo play is a tense, lonelier version of a game designed for three
Cover of Stellar Blade
Stellar Blade

2024 · Good

  • Parry and perfect-dodge combat is fast, precise and deeply satisfying
  • Boss fights are spectacular and demand genuine mastery
  • The story and world borrow heavily from NieR: Automata and Souls games

Where the gap is

Story
6.46.1
Gameplay
8.58.7
Longevity
7.97.3
Presentation
7.68.2

At a glance

FactElden Ring NightreignStellar Blade
Released30 May 202526 April 2024
DeveloperFromSoftwareShift Up, PlayStation Studios XDev
PublisherBandai Namco Entertainment, FromSoftwareSony Interactive Entertainment, PlayStation PC
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X|SPlayStation 5
DirectorJunya IshizakiKim Hyung-tae
EngineProprietary (FromSoftware in-house engine)Unreal Engine 4
GenreAction · RPG · RoguelikeAction · RPG · Sci-Fi

The two verdicts

Elden Ring Nightreign

Elden Ring Nightreign: an open world compressed into forty frantic minutes, best with friends

Nightreign is an experiment that mostly lands. FromSoftware has taken the slowest, most solitary form it knows and rebuilt it for speed and company, and in a coordinated trio the result is tense, funny and, at the Nightlord fights, as good as anything the studio has made in years. The score stays below the top tier for reasons that come from the same design: a game this tuned around three players frays when it has fewer, its map repeats sooner than the genre's best, and its borrowed world limits how much it can surprise returning fans. Post-launch updates have widened its appeal. The right audience is still a narrower one than the name on the box suggests.

Read the full review →

Stellar Blade

Stellar Blade has combat worth the hype and a story living on borrowed ideas

Stellar Blade features some of the best melee combat in recent action games, with thrilling boss fights and polished animation. A derivative story, empty open areas and weak supporting characters hold it back, leaving a good action game with notable issues rather than a genre-defining one.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.