Skip to content

Head to head

Erased vs Lazarus

Dead level: both score 7.7. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Erased
Erased

2016 · Good

  • An outstanding opening run that blends suspense with childhood nostalgia
  • Satoru and Kayo's bond is written with tenderness and restraint
  • The final episodes feel rushed and diverge from the manga's fuller story
Cover of Lazarus
Lazarus

2025 · Good

  • Fight and chase sequences are staged for clarity, with real weight behind each hit
  • The score mixes jazz, electronica and strings, and is never wallpaper
  • The central mystery is thinner than its setup promises

Where the gap is

Sound
8.48.8
Story
7.36.8
Animation
8.18.6
Characters
8.27.2

At a glance

FactErasedLazarus
Released8 January 20166 April 2025
StudioA-1 PicturesMAPPA
DirectorYūichirō Hirakawa, Tomohiko ItōShinichiro Watanabe
Episodes1213
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreDrama · Mystery · SuspenseAction · Sci-Fi · Thriller

The two verdicts

Erased

Erased: a superb time-travel mystery that runs short of breath at the finish

Erased is a gripping, beautifully crafted thriller whose opening episodes rank among the most compelling of their era. Its compressed finale, predictable mystery and underdeveloped present-day thread prevent it from reaching the heights its first half promised. It was widely popular on release and remains a common recommendation, and a 7.7 reflects a good series with an excellent start and notable issues.

Read the full review →

Lazarus

Lazarus: Watanabe's stylish thirteen-episode thriller, stronger in motion and music than in plot

Lazarus is a thoroughly enjoyable thriller whose strengths are almost all in its surface: precise, physical action, a distinctive and ambitious score, and a clean thirteen-episode shape that respects your time. Its weaknesses are in the foundations. The mystery does not build as it should, the cast is larger than the run can serve, and the tone wavers between cool and silly. That puts it a clear step below the director's best work, and short of the top tier, but still well above the average new action series. Watch it for the craft, expect less from the plot, and it will reward you.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.