Skip to content

Head to head

Fallout vs Mr. & Mrs. Smith

Fallout takes it by 0.4, 8.3 against 7.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Fallout
Fallout

2024 · Excellent

  • Walton Goggins is magnetic as both the Ghoul and his pre-war self
  • Captures the games' mix of 1950s optimism and grotesque violence
  • Juggling three storylines slows the middle episodes
Cover of Mr. & Mrs. Smith
Mr. & Mrs. Smith

2024 · Good

  • Glover and Erskine share an awkward, intimate and very real chemistry
  • Each mission neatly mirrors a stage of a developing relationship
  • The espionage plots are thin and often feel like a pretext

Where the gap is

Craft
8.98.2
Story
7.87.4
Characters
8.38.3
Performances
8.68.8

At a glance

FactFalloutMr. & Mrs. Smith
Released10 April 20242 February 2024
Created byGeneva Robertson Dworet, Graham WagnerDonald Glover, Francesca Sloane
StarringElla Purnell, Aaron Moten, Walton GogginsMaya Erskine, Donald Glover, Parker Posey
NetworkAmazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime Video
Seasons11
Episodes88
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · DramaAction · Drama · Comedy

The two verdicts

Fallout

Fallout: the game adaptation that nails the wasteland's gallows humour

Fallout scores 8.3 for a pitch-perfect translation of its source's tone, a superb Walton Goggins and production design that makes the wasteland feel tangible. Its sagging middle, reliance on lore and sometimes gratuitous violence stop it short of excellence across the board, but it sets a high bar for game adaptations and leaves plenty of ground to explore.

Read the full review →

Mr. & Mrs. Smith

Mr. & Mrs. Smith: a spy thriller that is really about the work of a relationship

Mr. & Mrs. Smith earns a 7.9 for its inventive premise, outstanding lead performances and clever structuring of espionage as a portrait of a relationship. Its thin spy plots, slow pace and rushed tonal shift in its final stretch keep it from excellence, but it is a smart, stylish and surprisingly moving reinvention.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.