Skip to content

Head to head

Fight Club vs No Country for Old Men

No Country for Old Men takes it by 0.8, 9.4 against 8.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Fight Club
Fight Club

1999 · Excellent

  • Brad Pitt's Tyler Durden is magnetic and genuinely unnerving
  • Fincher's restless, darkly comic direction keeps it thrilling
  • Its seductive nihilism has been embraced uncritically by many
Cover of No Country for Old Men
No Country for Old Men

2007 · Essential

  • Javier Bardem makes Anton Chigurh genuinely frightening without raising his voice
  • Near-absence of music turns every footstep and creaking door into suspense
  • The final stretch deliberately withholds the payoff many viewers expect

Where the gap is

Craft
8.99.6
Story
8.89.2
Direction
9.29.7
Performances
8.99.5

At a glance

FactFight ClubNo Country for Old Men
Released15 October 19999 November 2007
DirectorDavid FincherEthan Coen, Joel Coen
StarringBrad Pitt, Edward Norton, Helena Bonham CarterTommy Lee Jones, Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin
Runtime139 minutes122 minutes
StudioRegency Enterprises, 20th Century StudiosParamount Vantage, Miramax
GenreDrama · SuspenseDrama · Crime · Suspense

The two verdicts

Fight Club

Fight Club: a savage satire of consumer masculinity that is still widely misread

Fight Club is a bold, darkly funny and technically dazzling film, with outstanding performances and a structure that rewards repeat viewing. Its ideas remain provocative, although its blend of critique and glamour leaves it open to misreading, and its final act overreaches. It scores an 8.6 as one of the defining American films of the late 1990s.

Read the full review →

No Country for Old Men

No Country for Old Men: the Coens turn a chase thriller into a quiet elegy

No Country for Old Men won Best Picture and has only grown in stature since, and it earns that standing through near-flawless execution rather than spectacle. Direction, cinematography and performances all operate at the highest level. The only reason it stops just short of the very top of the scale is that its deliberately elusive final movement can leave first-time viewers unsettled rather than moved, even if repeat viewings reveal its design.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.