Skip to content

Head to head

From Hell vs The Dark Knight Returns

Dead level: both score 9.0. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of From Hell
From Hell

1989 · Essential

  • Eddie Campbell's scratchy ink turns Victorian London into a living, filthy nightmare
  • Gives the murdered women a humanity most Ripper fiction ignores
  • Long monologues and slow chapters test even patient readers
Cover of The Dark Knight Returns
The Dark Knight Returns

1986 · Essential

  • A thunderous, operatic vision of an ageing Batman that redefined the character
  • Dense, grid-based layouts create relentless momentum
  • Its politics are muddled and easily read as endorsing authoritarian violence

Where the gap is

Art
8.79.2
Story
9.18.9
Pacing
7.88.8
Characters
9.09.0

At a glance

FactFrom HellThe Dark Knight Returns
Released19891 February 1986
WriterAlan MooreFrank Miller
ArtistEddie C. Campbell—
Issues164
GenreHistory · Crime · HorrorSuperhero · Graphic Novel
Publisher—DC Comics

The two verdicts

From Hell

From Hell turns the Ripper murders into a hallucinatory autopsy of an empire

From Hell is a monumental, deeply researched and profoundly unsettling work that treats a much-exploited crime with rare intelligence and compassion for its victims. Its punishing pace, reliance on a discredited theory and unrelenting darkness make it hard going, and they account for the gap between this and a perfect score. A 9.0 honours an exceptional graphic novel that very few comics have matched for ambition.

Read the full review →

The Dark Knight Returns

The Dark Knight Returns still hits like a thunderclap, politics and all

The Dark Knight Returns is a ferocious, formally inventive and genuinely landmark work that redefined Batman and superhero storytelling. Its muddled politics, occasionally exhausting media segments and a legacy of grim imitators keep it from a perfect score. A 9.0 recognises an exceptional, still-powerful book that remains central to the medium's history.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.