Skip to content

Head to head

Get Lucky vs New Person, Same Old Mistakes

Get Lucky takes it by 0.6, 8.5 against 7.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Get Lucky
Get Lucky

2013 · Excellent

  • Nile Rodgers' chiming rhythm guitar is a masterclass in funk restraint
  • Pharrell's light, breezy vocal makes the song feel effortless
  • The six-minute album version repeats its loop longer than it needs to
Cover of New Person, Same Old Mistakes
  • A heavy, lurching groove that feels unusually physical for Tame Impala
  • Dense synth layers give the track an immersive, enveloping sound
  • Its slow tempo and six-minute length can feel sluggish in isolation

Where the gap is

Production
9.48.9
Performance
9.17.6
Songwriting
8.08.0
Replay value
8.67.7

At a glance

FactGet LuckyNew Person, Same Old Mistakes
Released19 April 201317 July 2015
ArtistDaft Punk, Pharrell WilliamsTame Impala
AlbumRandom Access MemoriesCurrents
LabelColumbia RecordsInterscope Records
Length6:096:03
GenreFunk · Electronic · DiscoAlternative rock · Electronic

The two verdicts

Get Lucky

Get Lucky: Daft Punk, Pharrell and Nile Rodgers bottle a perfect summer groove

Get Lucky earns an 8.5. Nile Rodgers' guitar, Pharrell's vocal and a world-class rhythm section make it one of the best-played pop hits of the 2010s. The lyric is barely there and the album version idles longer than it needs to, which keeps it below Daft Punk's most inventive work, but the groove still sounds effortless.

Read the full review →

New Person, Same Old Mistakes

New Person, Same Old Mistakes: Tame Impala close Currents with a heavy, honest shrug

New Person, Same Old Mistakes earns a 7.9. Its production is dense and assured, and as a closing statement it gives Currents a thoughtful, unresolved ending. As a standalone song it is slower and murkier than the album's best tracks, and its central argument is sometimes hard to hear through the effects.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.