Skip to content

Head to head

GNX vs Random Access Memories

Dead level: both score 8.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of GNX
GNX

2024 · Excellent

  • Lamar's rapping is sharp, varied and full of character throughout
  • Spotlights lesser-known Los Angeles rappers alongside SZA
  • Lacks the conceptual depth that defined his landmark records
Cover of Random Access Memories
Random Access Memories

2013 · Excellent

  • Recording quality and live musicianship of astonishing polish
  • Get Lucky and Instant Crush are warm, memorable pop songs
  • At well over an hour, mid-album tracks such as Motherboard drag

Where the gap is

Cohesion
7.87.6
Production
8.49.5
Performance
8.88.9
Songwriting
8.07.8

At a glance

FactGNXRandom Access Memories
Released22 November 202417 May 2013
ArtistKendrick LamarDaft Punk
LabelInterscope Records, PGLangColumbia Records
Tracks1213
Length44:0074:24
GenreHip-hopFunk · Electronic · Disco

The two verdicts

GNX

GNX: Kendrick Lamar's lean, victorious West Coast lap after the battle was won

GNX earns an 8.1. It is sharply performed, concise and full of personality, a confident follow-up that proves Lamar can be fun without losing his edge. What it lacks is the thematic weight and structural daring of his best work, and a few jarring shifts in tone keep it from feeling fully unified. As a statement of West Coast pride and creative freedom, though, it is hard to fault.

Read the full review →

Random Access Memories

Random Access Memories: Daft Punk's lavish, flawed love letter to live musicians

Random Access Memories scores 8.1. Its production, performances and best songs are superb, and its commercial and critical success, including a Grammy for Album of the Year, confirmed its standing. But its length, mid-album lull and occasional preference for homage over invention keep it from the top tier of Daft Punk's catalogue.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.