Skip to content

Head to head

Half-Life: Alyx vs Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Half-Life: Alyx
Half-Life: Alyx

2020 · Essential

  • Gravity gloves make grabbing and throwing objects feel magical
  • Physical reloading turns every firefight into a tense performance
  • Requires a capable PC and VR headset, limiting its audience
Cover of Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
  • An unprecedented roster spanning decades of Nintendo and third-party history
  • Faster, tighter fighting than the previous entry, accessible yet deep
  • Online play suffers from lag and inconsistent matchmaking

Where the gap is

Story
8.56.0
Gameplay
9.39.3
Longevity
7.49.6
Presentation
9.69.4

At a glance

FactHalf-Life: AlyxSuper Smash Bros. Ultimate
Released23 March 20207 December 2018
DeveloperValve, Campo SantoSora, Bandai Namco Studios
PublisherValveNintendo
PlatformsPC (Windows)Nintendo Switch
EngineSource 2Custom
GenreAction · Adventure · VRAction
Director—Masahiro Sakurai

The two verdicts

Half-Life: Alyx

Half-Life: Alyx is the rare game that justifies an entire hardware category

Half-Life: Alyx earns an exceptional score for setting the standard in VR interaction, atmosphere and design, while delivering a worthy Half-Life story. Narrow enemy variety, limited replay value and the barrier of expensive hardware keep it from a higher mark, but it remains the benchmark for what virtual reality games can be.

Read the full review →

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a museum of gaming that also plays brilliantly

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a generous, fast and finely tuned crossover fighter whose roster, stages and music make it a lasting celebration of the medium. Unreliable online play, a padded adventure mode and a slow unlocking process are its clearest failings, but they barely dent one of the finest party fighters ever made.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.