Skip to content

Head to head

Hellsing Ultimate vs Scott Pilgrim Takes Off

Dead level: both score 7.6. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Hellsing Ultimate
Hellsing Ultimate

2006 · Good

  • Alucard is a magnetic, terrifying antihero with an iconic visual presence
  • Committed to Hirano's excessive, grand-guignol style without compromise
  • Plotting is thin, with villains monologuing at extraordinary length
Cover of Scott Pilgrim Takes Off
  • Science SARU's vibrant animation captures the comic's video-game energy
  • Ramona and the evil exes gain welcome depth and personality
  • An early swerve away from the familiar story frustrates some viewers

Where the gap is

Sound
8.48.4
Story
7.07.2
Animation
8.09.1
Characters
7.97.8

At a glance

FactHellsing UltimateScott Pilgrim Takes Off
Released10 February 200617 November 2023
StudioMadhouse, GraphinicaScience Saru
Episodes108
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreAction · Seinen · HorrorAction · Comedy · Romance

The two verdicts

Hellsing Ultimate

Hellsing Ultimate: operatic vampire carnage with no interest in restraint

Hellsing Ultimate is an entertaining, stylish and gleefully excessive adaptation that captures the manga's spirit. Its thin plot, lengthy monologues, jarring comedy and inconsistent visuals keep it from greatness. It has a devoted following, particularly for its dub and Alucard, and a 7.6 reflects a good, often exhilarating series with notable issues.

Read the full review →

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off: a bold remix that trusts fans to follow it somewhere new

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off earns its score through gorgeous animation, a lively returning cast and a genuinely thoughtful expansion of characters who deserved more attention. Its central gamble will not work for everyone, and a compressed run and some navel-gazing in the finale blunt its impact, but it is a creative, affectionate reinvention rather than a simple nostalgia exercise.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.