Skip to content

Head to head

Hereditary vs Midsommar

Hereditary takes it by 0.5, 8.4 against 7.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Hereditary
Hereditary

2018 · Excellent

  • Toni Collette gives one of the great modern horror performances
  • A shocking early turn upends expectations with brutal force
  • The final act's occult explanations dilute the ambiguity
Cover of Midsommar
Midsommar

2019 · Good

  • Florence Pugh's raw portrayal of grief is extraordinary
  • Bright, sunlit horror imagery is genuinely original
  • Its long running time dilutes tension in the middle

Where the gap is

Craft
8.88.8
Story
8.07.3
Direction
8.98.6
Performances
9.48.9

At a glance

FactHereditaryMidsommar
Released8 June 20183 July 2019
DirectorAri AsterAri Aster
StarringToni Collette, Gabriel Byrne, Alex WolffFlorence Pugh, Jack Reynor, Will Poulter
Runtime127 minutes148 minutes
StudioPalmStar Media, A24A24
GenreDrama · Mystery · HorrorDrama · Mystery · Horror

The two verdicts

Hereditary

Hereditary: a grief-stricken family drama that curdles into pure dread

Hereditary is a gruelling, masterfully directed and superbly acted debut that uses horror to examine grief with rare intensity. Its explicit finale and punishing bleakness will not suit everyone, and the explanation of its mysteries is less powerful than the mysteries themselves. As one of the defining horror films of its era, it earns an 8.4.

Read the full review →

Midsommar

Midsommar: a sunlit break-up horror that turns daylight into dread

Midsommar is a bold, unsettling and visually stunning film anchored by a remarkable Florence Pugh performance, and it offers a truly original take on folk horror. Its length, predictable trajectory and thin supporting characters prevent it from reaching the level of Aster's debut. It earns a 7.9.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.