Skip to content

Head to head

Inside Out vs Inside Out 2

Inside Out takes it by 1.4, 9.0 against 7.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Inside Out
Inside Out

2015 · Essential

  • A brilliant visual metaphor for memory, personality and change
  • Its central insight about sadness is profound and rarely seen on screen
  • Anger, Fear and Disgust are funny but thinly developed
Cover of Inside Out 2
Inside Out 2

2024 · Good

  • Maya Hawke makes Anxiety frantic, funny and genuinely sympathetic
  • An anxiety attack sequence is vivid and emotionally resonant
  • Follows the original's journey structure far too closely

Where the gap is

Craft
9.08.3
Story
9.27.3
Direction
9.17.6
Performances
8.88.1

At a glance

FactInside OutInside Out 2
Released19 June 201514 June 2024
DirectorPete Docter, Ronnie del CarmenKelsey Mann
Runtime95 minutes96 minutes
StudioPixar, Walt Disney PicturesPixar, Walt Disney Pictures
GenreAdventure · Comedy · AnimationAdventure · Comedy · Animation

The two verdicts

Inside Out

Inside Out: Pixar's ingenious, deeply wise map of a child's emotional life

Inside Out is an ingenious, heartfelt and genuinely insightful film that works for children and adults on different levels. Its supporting emotions and real-world plot are less developed, but its central ideas and emotional payoff are exceptional. As one of the finest animated films of its decade, it earns a 9.0.

Read the full review →

Inside Out 2

Inside Out 2: a warm, perceptive sequel that gives Anxiety the keys

Inside Out 2 is a thoughtful, entertaining sequel that finds real insight in its portrayal of anxiety and adolescence, with Maya Hawke's performance a standout. Its reliance on the original's structure, a less inventive mind world and underused new emotions keep it firmly in the good-not-great tier. It earns a 7.6.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.