Skip to content

Head to head

iPhone 17 Pro vs iPod (first generation)

Dead level: both score 8.7. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of iPhone 17 Pro
iPhone 17 Pro

2025 · Excellent

  • A vapour chamber lets the A19 Pro hold its speed through long games and exports
  • Three 48 MP rear cameras, so 4x and 8x shots no longer fall off a cliff in detail
  • Anodised edges on the camera plateau chip and scuff, worst on the darker colours
Cover of iPod (first generation)
iPod (first generation)

2001 · Excellent

  • A scroll wheel that made a thousand-song list as quick to move through as ten
  • FireWire sync, rated by Apple at under ten minutes for a thousand songs
  • Mac-only at launch, with FireWire required, in a market that ran Windows

Where the gap is

Value
8.27.4
Design
7.99.6
Features
8.97.5
Performance
9.38.3

At a glance

FactiPhone 17 ProiPod (first generation)
Released19 September 202510 November 2001
MakerApple, FoxconnApple
TypeSmartphonePortable digital music player
OsiOS 26 at launchiPod software, built with PortalPlayer and Pixo; upgradable firmware
ChipA19 Pro (6-core CPU, 6-core GPU with Neural Accelerators, 16-core Neural Engine), vapour-chamber cooledPortalPlayer PP5002
PortsUSB-C, USB 3 (up to 10 Gb/s), DisplayPort outputFireWire 400 (IEEE 1394a), 3.5 mm headphone jack
GenreSmartphone · IosPortable media player · Audio

The two verdicts

iPhone 17 Pro

iPhone 17 Pro: Apple traded titanium for heat control, and the bet paid off

The iPhone 17 Pro scores where its engineering is strongest. Moving to an aluminium unibody with a vapour chamber was an unglamorous decision dressed up in a new colour, and it produced the most consistent performer Apple has made, paired with a camera system that no longer has a weak lens. The marks against it are physical: a finish that wears too readily at the plateau edges, a little more weight, and a launch price that rose faster than the storage justified for anyone who wanted 128 GB. With its successor now on sale, it is best bought discounted, where its strengths come at a fairer cost.

Read the full review →

iPod (first generation)

iPod (first generation): the music player that made the library portable

The first iPod was a narrower product than its reputation suggests: Mac-only, expensive, monochrome and hard to repair. It is scored as a device of its moment, and in that moment it was the clearest answer anyone had given to the problem of carrying a large music library. The small drive, the fast cable and the scroll wheel each removed a source of friction that rival players left in place, and together they made the category feel finished. Its features and its value were overtaken within a year by Apple's own revisions, and that keeps the score out of the top tier. The design and the idea were not overtaken for a decade, and that is why it sits as high as it does.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.