Skip to content

Head to head

iPhone 17 Pro vs Light Phone III

iPhone 17 Pro takes it by 1.6, 8.7 against 7.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of iPhone 17 Pro
iPhone 17 Pro

2025 · Excellent

  • A vapour chamber lets the A19 Pro hold its speed through long games and exports
  • Three 48 MP rear cameras, so 4x and 8x shots no longer fall off a cliff in detail
  • Anodised edges on the camera plateau chip and scuff, worst on the darker colours
Cover of Light Phone III
Light Phone III

2025 · Good

  • A matte OLED that fixes the slow, ghosting e-ink screen of the Light Phone II
  • A real camera with a physical shutter, so photos no longer mean carrying a second device
  • At $799 it costs as much as a mainstream flagship phone that can do far more

Where the gap is

Value
8.25.6
Design
7.98.7
Features
8.96.3
Performance
9.36.8

At a glance

FactiPhone 17 ProLight Phone III
Released19 September 202527 March 2025
MakerApple, FoxconnLight Phone Inc.
TypeSmartphoneMinimalist phone
OsiOS 26 at launchLightOS (Android-based, no app store and no Google services)
ChipA19 Pro (6-core CPU, 6-core GPU with Neural Accelerators, 16-core Neural Engine), vapour-chamber cooledQualcomm Snapdragon 4 Gen 2 (SM4450)
PortsUSB-C, USB 3 (up to 10 Gb/s), DisplayPort outputUSB-C
GenreSmartphone · IosSmartphone · Minimalist phone

The two verdicts

iPhone 17 Pro

iPhone 17 Pro: Apple traded titanium for heat control, and the bet paid off

The iPhone 17 Pro scores where its engineering is strongest. Moving to an aluminium unibody with a vapour chamber was an unglamorous decision dressed up in a new colour, and it produced the most consistent performer Apple has made, paired with a camera system that no longer has a weak lens. The marks against it are physical: a finish that wears too readily at the plateau edges, a little more weight, and a launch price that rose faster than the storage justified for anyone who wanted 128 GB. With its successor now on sale, it is best bought discounted, where its strengths come at a fairer cost.

Read the full review →

Light Phone III

Light Phone III: the best-made way to own less phone, at a price that asks for faith

The Light Phone III succeeds at the hard part. It turns a philosophy into a phone that is pleasant to hold, quick to use and built to last, and it fixes nearly every practical complaint about the e-ink model before it. The design score reflects that. What holds the overall mark in the low sevens is everything around the object: a price that puts it beside phones that can do vastly more, features that shipped on the spec sheet before they shipped in software, and a battery that leaves little margin on a demanding day. For the right owner, those reservations matter less than the quiet it buys. For everyone else, a smartphone with stricter settings is the cheaper experiment to run first.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.