Skip to content

Head to head

iPod (first generation) vs Sony Walkman TPS-L2

Sony Walkman TPS-L2 takes it by 0.2, 8.9 against 8.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of iPod (first generation)
iPod (first generation)

2001 · Excellent

  • A scroll wheel that made a thousand-song list as quick to move through as ten
  • FireWire sync, rated by Apple at under ten minutes for a thousand songs
  • Mac-only at launch, with FireWire required, in a market that ran Windows
Cover of Sony Walkman TPS-L2
Sony Walkman TPS-L2

1979 · Excellent

  • Stereo cassette playback in a body that fits a coat pocket, from a single pair of AA cells
  • A second headphone jack turned private listening into something two people could share
  • At 390 g it is heavy for a pocket, and the WM-2 made it look bulky within two years

Where the gap is

Value
7.48.1
Design
9.69.6
Features
7.57.4
Performance
8.37.6

At a glance

FactiPod (first generation)Sony Walkman TPS-L2
Released10 November 20011 July 1979
MakerAppleSony
TypePortable digital music playerPortable stereo cassette player
OsiPod software, built with PortalPlayer and Pixo; upgradable firmware—
ChipPortalPlayer PP5002—
PortsFireWire 400 (IEEE 1394a), 3.5 mm headphone jackTwo headphone jacks (A and B), DC IN 3 V socket
GenrePortable media player · AudioPortable media player · Audio
Weight—390 g
Battery—Two AA (1.5 V) cells; external 3 V DC input

The two verdicts

iPod (first generation)

iPod (first generation): the music player that made the library portable

The first iPod was a narrower product than its reputation suggests: Mac-only, expensive, monochrome and hard to repair. It is scored as a device of its moment, and in that moment it was the clearest answer anyone had given to the problem of carrying a large music library. The small drive, the fast cable and the scroll wheel each removed a source of friction that rival players left in place, and together they made the category feel finished. Its features and its value were overtaken within a year by Apple's own revisions, and that keeps the score out of the top tier. The design and the idea were not overtaken for a decade, and that is why it sits as high as it does.

Read the full review →

Sony Walkman TPS-L2

Sony Walkman TPS-L2: the cassette player that took music out of the room

The TPS-L2 earns its score as the device that defined personal listening, not as the best cassette player Sony made. Its engineering is modest by design: a journalist's recorder with parts taken away, a mechanical transport, a heavy metal case. Those subtractions are exactly what made it new, because they left a machine that did one thing and did it through headphones, wherever the owner went. The two jacks and the Hotline show its makers unsure of what they had built, which is part of what makes it worth studying. It loses marks for weight, for a feature set its own successor overtook within two years, and for the servicing any surviving example demands. As an object of design history it is close to essential.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.