Skip to content

Head to head

It vs The Shining

The Shining takes it by 0.9, 8.6 against 7.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of It
It

1986 · Good

  • The Losers' Club is one of King's most tender portraits of friendship
  • Captures the textures and terrors of childhood with piercing accuracy
  • Its immense length includes long stretches that could have been cut
Cover of The Shining
The Shining

1977 · Excellent

  • Jack's descent is rooted in addiction, rage and guilt, not just ghosts
  • Danny's perspective makes the supernatural terrors intensely vivid
  • The slow first third may test readers expecting early scares

Where the gap is

Ideas
7.88.1
Story
7.48.7
Writing
7.88.3
Characters
9.09.1

At a glance

FactItThe Shining
Released15 September 198628 January 1977
AuthorStephen KingStephen King
PublisherQanunDoubleday
Pages1138447
GenreDrama · HorrorDrama · Horror

The two verdicts

It

It: Stephen King's monstrous, overstuffed epic of childhood fear and friendship

It is a flawed monument: overlong, uneven and marred by a grave misjudgement, but also rich in feeling, atmosphere and some of the most vivid characters in popular fiction. The Losers' friendship and the portrait of a poisoned town are exceptional. The excess and the weaker late material pull the overall score down to good rather than great.

Read the full review →

The Shining

The Shining: Stephen King's haunted hotel is a family tragedy with teeth

The Shining is a superb blend of supernatural horror and family tragedy, anchored by rich characters and a brilliantly realised setting. Its slow start, uneven set pieces and a dated character trope keep it from the very top tier, but its emotional depth and sustained dread make it one of King's finest and most enduring novels.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.