Skip to content

Head to head

Kid A vs Lux

Dead level: both score 9.3. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Kid A
Kid A

2000 · Essential

  • A total reinvention that avoids every obvious move after OK Computer
  • Everything in Its Right Place is one of the great album openers
  • Treefingers' ambient drift halts momentum for some listeners
Cover of Lux
Lux

2025 · Essential

  • A full symphony orchestra used as a rhythm section, not as a string pad
  • Rosalía's voice moves from flamenco melisma to operatic head voice within a phrase
  • Three songs, including the striking "Jeanne", were missing from streaming for months

Where the gap is

Cohesion
9.58.9
Production
9.69.6
Performance
9.19.7
Songwriting
9.09.1

At a glance

FactKid ALux
Released2 October 20007 November 2025
ArtistRadioheadRosalia
LabelParlophone, Capitol RecordsColumbia Records
Tracks1018
Length49:5760:05
GenreAlternative rock · Art rock · ElectronicFlamenco · Classical · Art pop

The two verdicts

Kid A

Kid A: Radiohead dismantle rock music and build something eerie and lasting

Kid A scores 9.3. Its production, cohesion and sheer audacity make it one of the most significant albums of its time, and its reputation has only grown. It stops short of the landmark tier because some of its individual songs are less compelling than the whole, and its emotional distance can make it more admired than loved. Few records have taken such a risk and been so thoroughly vindicated.

Read the full review →

Lux

Lux: Rosalía trades the club for the cathedral and loses none of her nerve

*Lux* is the work of an artist who could have repeated a winning formula and chose the hardest possible alternative. The orchestra is used with wit and force, the guests are chosen with care, and the singing is on a level few contemporaries reach. What holds the score below the very top is not a lack of ambition but its weight: a concept that sometimes lives more in the explanations than in the songs, and a final movement that loses momentum. Those reservations matter less with each listen. It is the most ambitious album of her career, and one of the most rewarding of the decade so far.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.