Skip to content

Head to head

Lemonade vs My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy takes it by 0.2, 9.0 against 8.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Lemonade
Lemonade

2016 · Excellent

  • Beyoncé's most emotionally raw and commanding vocal performances
  • A strong narrative arc from suspicion and fury to healing
  • Some of its impact depends on the accompanying film
Cover of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
  • Some of the most lavish, meticulously layered production in hip-hop
  • Runaway is a brave, extended piece of self-examination
  • The misogyny in several lyrics is hard to ignore

Where the gap is

Cohesion
8.79.0
Production
9.09.7
Performance
9.48.8
Songwriting
8.98.9

At a glance

FactLemonadeMy Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
Released23 April 201622 November 2010
ArtistBeyonceKanye West
LabelParkwood Entertainment, Columbia RecordsRoc-A-Fella Records, Def Jam Recordings
Tracks1213
Length45:4268:36
GenreHip-hop · Pop · R&BHip-hop · Pop

The two verdicts

Lemonade

Lemonade: Beyoncé turns betrayal into a genre-spanning statement of power

Lemonade scores 8.8 as an excellent, era-defining album. Its performances are among the finest in modern pop, its narrative is compelling, and its cultural resonance is profound. It falls just short of the exceptional tier because a few tracks feel more like connective moments than fully developed songs, and because some of its power depends on the visual work that accompanies it. As a statement of artistic and personal independence, it remains remarkable.

Read the full review →

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy: maximalism as confession, ego as art

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy scores 9.0: an exceptional album whose production, sequencing and ambition place it among the most important hip-hop records ever made. Its lyrics can be ugly as well as honest, and several songs sprawl beyond their best ideas, which keeps it below the landmark tier. But as a portrait of ego, self-loathing and grandeur rendered in sound, it has rarely been matched.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.