Skip to content

Head to head

MacBook Air 15" M3 vs MacBook Pro 16" M4 Max

MacBook Pro 16" M4 Max takes it by 0.4, 9.1 against 8.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of MacBook Air 15" M3
MacBook Air 15" M3

2024 · Excellent

  • Completely silent operation with no fan to spin up
  • Large, bright display in a thin, light chassis
  • Launch base model shipped with only 8GB of memory
Cover of MacBook Pro 16" M4 Max
MacBook Pro 16" M4 Max

2024 · Essential

  • M4 Max handles heavy video, 3D and compile workloads with ease
  • Up to 128GB of unified memory suits large models and datasets
  • Price rises steeply as memory and storage are configured

Where the gap is

Value
8.46.9
Design
9.28.8
Features
8.29.2
Performance
8.39.8

At a glance

FactMacBook Air 15" M3MacBook Pro 16" M4 Max
Released8 March 20248 November 2024
MakerAppleApple
ChipM3M4 Max
Memory8-24GB36-128GB unified
Battery18h24h
GenreLaptopLaptop

The two verdicts

MacBook Air 15" M3

MacBook Air 15-inch M3: the sensible laptop most people should simply buy

The MacBook Air 15-inch M3 scores 8.7 because it does almost everything most people need, silently and for a long time on a charge, in a beautifully made and comfortable package. It falls short of exceptional because of the stingy base memory at launch, limited ports and the performance ceiling of a fanless design. Once Apple raised base memory, it became close to the definitive mainstream laptop.

Read the full review →

MacBook Pro 16" M4 Max

MacBook Pro 16-inch M4 Max: desktop-class power with almost no compromise

The MacBook Pro 16-inch M4 Max scores 9.1 because it sets the standard for performance, efficiency and display quality in a laptop, with a thoughtful port selection and excellent battery life. It is not flawless: the price escalates dramatically, the machine is heavy, and value drops sharply for anyone who will not use its headroom. For those who will, there is little to rival it.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.