Skip to content

Head to head

Made in Abyss vs Violet Evergarden

Made in Abyss takes it by 0.2, 8.5 against 8.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Made in Abyss
Made in Abyss

2017 · Excellent

  • The Abyss is one of the most imaginative, awe-inspiring settings in anime
  • Kevin Penkin's score is sweeping, strange and utterly unforgettable
  • Graphic suffering inflicted on child characters can feel gratuitous
Cover of Violet Evergarden
Violet Evergarden

2018 · Excellent

  • Some of the most lavish, detailed animation ever made for television
  • Standout episodes deliver genuinely devastating emotional payoffs
  • Episodic tearjerker structure can feel manipulative and formulaic

Where the gap is

Sound
9.59.0
Story
8.67.8
Animation
9.29.9
Characters
8.58.2

At a glance

FactMade in AbyssViolet Evergarden
Released7 July 201711 January 2018
StudioKinema CitrusKyoto Animation
DirectorMasayuki KojimaTaichi Ishidate
Episodes2513
StatusAiringCompleted
GenreAdventure · Drama · FantasyDrama · Fantasy · Slice of Life

The two verdicts

Made in Abyss

Made in Abyss: a wondrous descent that turns cruelty into its signature

Made in Abyss is a visually stunning, musically extraordinary adventure with a world unlike any other. Its excessive, sometimes exploitative cruelty and fragmented release structure are significant flaws that divide audiences. It remains a critically acclaimed, highly distinctive work, and an 8.5 reflects an excellent series whose brilliance and discomfort are inseparable.

Read the full review →

Violet Evergarden

Violet Evergarden: Kyoto Animation's ravishing weepie about learning to feel

Violet Evergarden earns its score through extraordinary animation, a beautiful score and several episodes of genuinely devastating emotional power. A formulaic episodic structure, slow early episodes and a thin overarching plot keep it below the top tier, but as a heartfelt, meticulously crafted drama it remains essential viewing, best followed by its films, particularly the 2020 feature that concludes Violet's story.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.