Skip to content

Head to head

Marty Supreme vs Past Lives

Dead level: both score 8.8. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Marty Supreme
Marty Supreme

2025 · Excellent

  • Chalamet plays a charmer the film refuses to forgive, and is magnetic anyway
  • Table tennis rallies shot with the clarity and menace of a boxing match
  • At 150 minutes, the middle stretch repeats the same scam-and-escape rhythm
Cover of Past Lives
Past Lives

2023 · Excellent

  • Greta Lee conveys two cultures and two versions of herself with great subtlety
  • John Magaro's Arthur is a rare, generous portrait of the other man
  • Its unhurried, low-key rhythm will feel too slight for some viewers

Where the gap is

Craft
9.18.4
Story
8.28.9
Direction
9.18.8
Performances
9.49.1

At a glance

FactMarty SupremePast Lives
Released6 October 20252 June 2023
DirectorJosh SafdieCeline Song
StarringTimothee Chalamet, Gwyneth Paltrow, Odessa A'zionGreta Lee, Yoo Teo, John Magaro
Runtime150 minutes106 minutes
StudioA24—
GenreDrama · Comedy · HistoricalDrama · Romance

The two verdicts

Marty Supreme

Marty Supreme: a sports film that runs like a heist and never asks you to like its champion

Marty Supreme takes the most familiar shape in sports cinema, the outsider chasing a title, and fills it with a hero who would rather win than be loved. That bet pays off because Chalamet makes Marty's hunger physical and specific, because Khondji and Fisk build a 1950s New York with grit under its fingernails, and because Safdie stages table tennis as if lives depended on it. The score is held below the top tier by a sagging middle hour that repeats its scams once too often, and by a script more interested in the women as obstacles or rewards than as people. Those flaws are real. They are also the cost of a film that moves with this much nerve, and that few directors would have dared to make at this scale.

Read the full review →

Past Lives

Past Lives: Celine Song's debut is a quiet, devastating film about choices

Past Lives is a small film with a vast emotional reach, widely acclaimed on release and embraced as one of the finest debuts of its decade. Its performances are exquisite and its restraint is its strength. A slightly slack middle section and a deliberately understated scale mean it stops short of the very highest scores, but its closing scenes stay with the viewer long after the credits.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.