Skip to content

Head to head

Masters of the Air vs Shōgun

Shōgun takes it by 2.0, 9.1 against 7.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Masters of the Air
Masters of the Air

2024 · Good

  • Air combat sequences convey the terror and confinement of a bomber
  • Honours a true story of staggering losses with real seriousness
  • Airmen blur together behind oxygen masks and similar uniforms
Cover of Shōgun
Shōgun

2024 · Essential

  • Anna Sawai gives Mariko a quiet steel that anchors the whole series
  • Japanese perspectives drive the story rather than framing a foreign hero
  • The deliberate pace in early episodes demands real patience

Where the gap is

Craft
8.19.5
Story
7.09.0
Characters
6.49.2
Performances
7.49.3

At a glance

FactMasters of the AirShōgun
Released26 January 202427 February 2024
StarringAustin Butler, Callum Turner, Anthony BoyleCosmo Jarvis, Hiroyuki Sanada, Anna Sawai
NetworkApple TV+FX on Hulu
Seasons11
Episodes910
GenreDrama · History · WarAdventure · Drama · History
Created by—Rachel Kondo, Justin Marks

The two verdicts

Masters of the Air

Masters of the Air: a stirring aerial war epic that struggles to find its crews

Masters of the Air earns a 7.1 for its vivid depiction of the bomber war, admirable historical seriousness and a few standout performances. Its thin characterisation, clichéd dialogue and occasionally artificial visuals keep it well short of its illustrious predecessors, though it remains a worthwhile tribute to a remarkable chapter of history.

Read the full review →

Shōgun

Shōgun: a patient, gorgeous epic that makes feudal politics feel like a thriller

Shōgun earns its acclaim through intelligence as much as spectacle. Its performances are superb, its craft is exceptional and its storytelling respects both its source and its audience. A slightly slow start and a less vivid English lead are the only real reservations, and they barely dent a score of 9.1 for a drama that deserves its place among the finest of its decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.