Skip to content

Head to head

Midsommar vs Nosferatu

Dead level: both score 7.9. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Midsommar
Midsommar

2019 · Good

  • Florence Pugh's raw portrayal of grief is extraordinary
  • Bright, sunlit horror imagery is genuinely original
  • Its long running time dilutes tension in the middle
Cover of Nosferatu
Nosferatu

2024 · Good

  • Near-monochrome photography makes every candlelit room feel diseased
  • Bill Skarsgard's Orlok is a physically grotesque, genuinely unsettling presence
  • The familiar story offers few surprises for anyone who knows the source

Where the gap is

Craft
8.89.2
Story
7.37.2
Direction
8.68.5
Performances
8.97.8

At a glance

FactMidsommarNosferatu
Released3 July 201925 December 2024
DirectorAri AsterRobert Eggers
StarringFlorence Pugh, Jack Reynor, Will PoulterBill Skarsgård, Nicholas Hoult, Lily-Rose Depp
Runtime148 minutes132 minutes
StudioA24Focus Features, Stillking Films
GenreDrama · Mystery · HorrorDrama · Fantasy · Horror

The two verdicts

Midsommar

Midsommar: a sunlit break-up horror that turns daylight into dread

Midsommar is a bold, unsettling and visually stunning film anchored by a remarkable Florence Pugh performance, and it offers a truly original take on folk horror. Its length, predictable trajectory and thin supporting characters prevent it from reaching the level of Aster's debut. It earns a 7.9.

Read the full review →

Nosferatu

Nosferatu: Robert Eggers delivers a lavish, suffocating gothic nightmare

Nosferatu is a triumph of design and mood, anchored by a monstrous central performance and an ambitious reorientation around Ellen. It was widely praised on release, and deservedly so for its craft. Its predictable story and emotional distance hold it back from the masterpiece territory its images sometimes reach, which places it firmly among the very good rather than the essential.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.