Skip to content

Head to head

Millennium Actress vs Nana

Millennium Actress takes it by 0.5, 9.1 against 8.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Millennium Actress
Millennium Actress

2001 · Essential

  • Cuts between memory and film set mid-gesture, so the edit itself tells the story
  • Two interviewers inside the flashbacks turn a biography into a comedy double act
  • Chiyoko is defined almost entirely by one longing, which flattens her at times
Cover of Nana
Nana

2006 · Excellent

  • Two leads written with unusual honesty about desire, jealousy and dependence
  • Treats adult relationships, sex and money without coyness or melodrama
  • Ends at an unresolved point because the source manga went on hiatus

Where the gap is

Sound
9.38.8
Story
9.28.4
Animation
9.47.6
Characters
8.69.3

At a glance

FactMillennium ActressNana
Released28 July 20015 April 2006
StudioMadhouseMadhouse
DirectorSatoshi Kon—
Episodes1 (feature film)47
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreDrama · Romance · HistoricalDrama · Romance · Slice of Life

The two verdicts

Millennium Actress

Millennium Actress: a life story told as one long, breathless edit

*Millennium Actress* takes a simple frame, an old woman telling her story to a camera, and uses it to show what animation can do that live action struggles to: move a body from one century to another in a single cut, and make the move feel inevitable. Kon's editing, Honda's drawing and Hirasawa's score combine into something that plays like one long, accelerating gesture. The score stops short of the top tier because the heroine is a single note for much of the film and the chase structure repeats more than it develops. Neither costs it much. It remains the warmest of Kon's films, the most accessible, and a compact argument that the history of cinema and the memory of one life can be told as the same story.

Read the full review →

Nana

Nana: a raw, grown-up romance about friendship and the cost of wanting things

Nana earns its score through characters, not spectacle. Its two leads are among the most fully realised women in the medium, and its view of early adulthood is honest in a way that still stings. Limited animation, a sagging middle and an ending that simply stops keep it short of the very top tier, but for viewers willing to accept an open conclusion, it is an essential drama.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.