Skip to content

Head to head

Minecraft vs Portal 2

Portal 2 takes it by 0.2, 9.6 against 9.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Minecraft
Minecraft

2011 · Essential

  • Near-limitless freedom to build, explore and set personal goals
  • Survival mode offers a gentle but compelling loop of danger and progress
  • Minimal guidance leaves newcomers reliant on outside help for recipes
Cover of Portal 2
Portal 2

2011 · Masterpiece

  • New tools such as gels and light bridges keep puzzles inventive to the end
  • Superb comic writing and voice performances from GLaDOS, Wheatley and Cave Johnson
  • Puzzles usually have one intended solution, limiting improvisation

Where the gap is

Story
5.59.4
Gameplay
9.59.5
Longevity
10.08.6
Presentation
8.09.3

At a glance

FactMinecraftPortal 2
Released18 November 201119 April 2011
PublisherMicrosoft GamingValve
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X|SPC (Windows), PlayStation 3
EngineJava/BedrockSource
GenreAdventure · IndieAdventure
Developer—Valve

The two verdicts

Minecraft

Minecraft remains the purest expression of play a video game has managed

Minecraft combines accessible systems with near-infinite creative depth, and years of updates have only broadened its appeal. Its lack of guidance, simple combat and fragmented editions are genuine drawbacks, but few games have given players so much freedom or had such lasting influence, which justifies a place near the very top of the scale.

Read the full review →

Portal 2

Portal 2 turned a brilliant experiment into a complete, hilarious masterpiece

Portal 2 builds on a brilliant concept with a wealth of new mechanics, sharply paced puzzles, an outstanding co-op campaign and some of the best comic writing in video games. Limited replay value and mostly single-solution puzzles are minor, and together its craft and humour justify its status as an all-time landmark.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.